“Effective teaching can be measured” — with test scores, of course!

Today, the Gates Foundation released its third and final component of the Measuring Effective Teachers project – the big education reform study led by Harvard economist Thomas Kane.

“Effective teaching can be measured,” the authors wrote in the latest installment. They’re sure of it because they used a randomized experiment to figure it out. Reliable teacher evaluations, the paper claims, include “balanced” proportions of teacher observation, students’ standardized test scores and student surveys. And for the first time, the randomized trial shows that teachers who perform well with one group of students, on average, perform at the same levels with different groups of kids.

Incentive programs like Race to the Top are forcing school districts to change their teacher evaluation systems to rely heavily on test scores, and the important components of observations and student feedback are often left out of the equation.  This study shows that, simply put, a good teacher is a good teacher with any set of random kids.  The problem will always remain how to measure the “good teacher” part.

In these days of Educational Reform, teachers are finding themselves more and more tossed by the various pressures arising from high stakes testing.  There does need to be a reliable way of ensuring that students are receiving the best education possible.  But I think that the contemporary method of putting all the results and all the blame on the teachers alone is not the way to ensure better education or even more rigor.  Good teachers will rise to higher standards and requirements, but simply judging them on the often arbitrary results of standardized student test scores is not the way to ensure that kind of performance.


One thought on ““Effective teaching can be measured” — with test scores, of course!

  1. I’m not sure if there’s a school-based team (consisting of the thceaer, school counsellor, vice principal etc) but I’d meet with them and discuss the issue and how best to approach the issue. Perhaps the child needs to spend some time with the school counsellor. Also, maybe have a meeting with the parents and the child. Let the child know that you have their best interest at heart and that you want the child to be their best self. Together with the child, create a contract with consequences. If they do this, they get ___ but if they don’t do it, they have something taken away like computer/tv time. But the parents also need to have some responsibility/consequences as well. By creating a contract together with the child, their input/negotion should encourage them to follow it. Sounds airy-fairy but it just might help. 🙂

What do you think?

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s